Lambs Blacksheep Spiced Rum
Review Revisitation: Lambs Blacksheep Spiced Rum (85/100)
A Review Revisited by Chip Dykstra (Aka Arctic Wolf)
Revision published June 23. 2010
It is time for another review revisitation. I have returned to this very early review which was part of the original set of reviews I opened the blog with, but which upon further reflection required a more thorough study. Lamb’s Blacksheep Rum is a really fun rum for me, but I had better warn you that the rum will not be for all palates. It is supercharged with cinnamon as the main spice so if cinnamon is not your thing you may want to take that into account.
History
Alfred Lamb is presumed to have opened his wine and spirits business in London in 1849. His method of aging rum in his cellars under the Thames River is reputed to be one of the secrets behind his rum’s unexpectedly smooth taste. Lamb’s Blacksheep Spiced Rum is a relatively new offering from Lamb’s and is part of the Corby stable of North American Brands. This is what the Corby’s website has to say regarding the Blacksheep…
“…Lamb’s® Black Sheep Spiced Rum is produced and blended in small batches to ensure consistency of the complex flavour profile that is unique to the rum category. Our ingredients – the finest cinnamon from Korintje,Madagascar-bourbon vanilla and lime essence from Mexico have been carefully selected from around the world to ensure optimal enjoyment on the palate…”
As you can see, the typical hexagonal Lamb’s bottle is attractive as is the professional label with attractive fonts and colors which hint at the cinnamon flavours found inside. The presentation is quite satisfactory. The plastic screw cap is much preferred over those pressed on metal caps I still see, but a nice satisfying cork would have been grand.
In the Glass: (8.5)
I noticed a light amount of oil in the glass with skinny legs that swim back into the rum when the glass is tilted. The strong aroma of cinnamon is in the air as is a healthy dose of vanilla. As I mentioned in my original review, this reminds me of those tiny red heart-shaped candies I used to buy as a kid.
Behind the cinnamon and the vanilla is a mild caramel scent but I detect very little if any oak or woody tannin.
In the Mouth (50.5)
I would classify this rum as a mixer rather than a sipper. It’s not that I can’t sip Lamb’s Blacksheep, I can and occasionally I do; but, the flavour profile is like a sweet cinnamon candy. I love this overcharge of cinnamon, and the inviting vanilla underneath, but drinking it neat is kind of like nibbling that sweet candy. You like it, but if you have it too often the flavours become cloying.
Mixed with cola is a whole other matter, the Blacksheep is delicious mixed. In fact, Lamb’s Blacksheep rum does not need to be mixed with cola, it is very versatile. I made a great spiced peach punch for my Superbowl party this year using the Lamb’s Blacksheep as the base spirit, and earlier in my explorations (last Christmas) I made some wicked rum balls.
In the Throat (13.0)
The finish is all cinnamon and vanilla, with a nice kick that stems from the spice rather than the alcohol. This is a 75 proof spirit, which is slightly higher than most spiced rums in the market place, but I really wish it had more alcohol kick to go with the cinnamon kick.
The Afterburn (8.5)
When I first tried this rum I was surprised and delighted by the unique flavor profile. Over time I have found that its flavour profile can become a touch cloying if I return too often; but, I still love using this rum for mixed cocktails where the unique spiced attitude works extremely well.
Suggested Recipes:
The recipe was my Superbowl creation and is one of the few punches I know of with real peach juice. So for now I will call it my:
Here is the recipe:
1 cup Lamb’s Blacksheep Spiced Rum
1/2 cup Appleton Estate VX Rum
1/4 cup Triple Sec
2 cups Peach Juice
3 cups Orange Juice
1/4 cup Lime Juice
3 tbsp Simple Syrup
Garnish Punch Bowl with slices of peach fruit
Finish with Large Ice Cubes
I find this to be a very refreshing drink and as you can see I fill my glass to the brim!
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
1 1/2 cup finely chopped nuts (A mixture of walnuts, pecans, and almonds)
1 1/2 cup icing sugar
4 oz grated dark bittersweet chocolate
1/3 cup Lamb’s Blacksheep Rum
1 tsp Real Vanilla Extract
1 or 2 Dairy Milk chocolate bars
Here’s how to make them:
Place the Dairy Milk bars in the refrigerator to keep them hard so they are easy to grate later.
Make sure the nuts and the first amount of chocolate is very finely chopped and grated.
Mix the first five ingredients together and form into a small ball.
Refrigerate the mixture for 1/2 hour.
When you take the mix from the refrigerator, Take about a tablespoon at a time and roll the dough into 1 1/2 inch balls.
Cover the balls with the second amount of finely grated Dairy Milk bars.
Place back on the wax paper in the flat Tupperware and seal, refrigerate until you are ready to eat them. Yumm!
……………………………………………………………………………………..
Note For comparison I have left my original review below:
……………………………………………………………………………………..
Review: Lambs Blacksheep Spiced Rum 89pts
A Review by Chip Dykstra (Aka Arctic Wolf)

In the Bottle: (4.0)
Typical Lambs bottle, nothing special but nothing bad either.
In the Glass: (9.0)
Do you remember those tiny heart shaped red candies with the strong cinnamon smell? You do, okay that is exactly what I smell here. Combined with the dark rum aromas this is very enticing.
In the Mouth (54.0)
This is yummy. An explosion of cinnamon toast and molasses. Somehow it works instead of going awry. Mixed with coke this is even better.
In the Throat (13.0)
The odd flavours do not settle as it goes down but the experience is well worth repeating. This isn’t your average spiced rum but a spiced rum on cinnamon steroids. Unlike the Captain Morgan Private Stock which is Vanilla on steroids, this mixture works!
The Afterburn (9.0)
What a really refreshing change. The overcharge of cinnamon really gets me. I heartily recommend this Rum to all who like cinnamon toast.
This review was first posted on:
………………………………………………………………………………………
If you found this review helpful or interesting then these reviews and/or articles may help you as well:



RG said
Best tasting rum ever!! Nice smooth and satisfying flavour.Great vanilla notes and mildly spicy.Mixed with coke or diet cola is good and not too sweet.
Arctic Wolf said
Glad you liked this Rum RG. Have you tried other Spiced Rums?
Boxy said
I just picked up my first bottle of Black Sheep last weekend. Wow! I first tried it straight – about 1/2 an ounce – and was amazed. It goes with just about anything, whether a simple rum & coke or an exotic cocktail. I used it in a cocktail called a Tahitian Tiki Moon, and received compliments all evening. I’ve previously used Sailor Jerry (which I still like, don’t get me wrong) but Black Sheep definitely has a place in my home bar.
Arctic Wolf said
I am curious Boxy, What exactly is a Tahitian Tiki Moon?
Boxy said
The ingredients are:
• 2 oz Light Rum
• 1 oz Coconut Rum
• 1 1/2 oz Vanilla Rum
• 2 oz Orange Juice
• 1 oz Pineapple Juice
• 2-3 oz Cream
• 1 tsp Vanilla Extract
I subbed Black Sheep for the Light Rum.
I can’t take credit for this – I found the recipe on the internet.
Jeff Allen said
Outstanding with eggnog.
Very good at Xmas.
Prof said
Wow this is good stuff!! Great with ginger ale!!
Looking forward to trying other Lamb’s products and that Sailor Jerry’s sounds interesting too.
How does Capt Morgan’s Spiced compare and are there other ones that I should check out. I assume that each one is different than the other even though they are all called ‘spiced rum’.
Prof said
oop gotta check out the articles on the right
—>
Rick said
Try Black Sheep with Coke lime or Pepsi lime, it is superb.
Murray said
Tried it last year, by far the best, smoothest, tasting RUM, BLACK SHEEP! I have all my friends trying it and enjoying it!
Wahid Akhram said
Good!